So you’ve decided you want to become a physician assistant, and soon you’ll be sending out PA training program applications. Letters of recommendation can be a pivotal part of the process, so you have some things to keep in mind to maximize your chance of acceptance. The following checklist should help avoid critical mistakes.

1. Start tracking your letters down early. You should start asking references if they are willing to write you a letter early because it takes time to secure an agreement from writers, it takes time for your references to actually write their letters and submit them, and generally speaking, the earlier your application is complete, the better your chances of getting in. This is particularly true if you apply through CASPA.

2. Use references that will have broad appeal. Most schools will have you apply via the Central Application Service for Physician Assistants (CASPA). CASPA requires you to obtain three letters of reference. Once received, CASPA will distribute the same three letters to each school to which you are applying. For this reason, you should choose references that will have appeal to the widest range of schools. If you are concerned about appealing to the specific requirements of a particular school, you can speak to these in your essay, or in a secondary application, which you may complete later in the application process.

3. Clinical references are usually better than academic references. In most cases, schools prefer to learn about your clinical experiences than you academic performance. This means seeking out references who have supervised you or worked closely with you in a clinical (patient) setting. It makes sense, because this information speaks directly about your potential as a PA. The only exception is if you have a weak academic background (low grades or your coursework is more than 3 years old). In this case, you should consider getting one letter from the instructor of a class that you did well in, preferably in a science prerequisite.

4. Seek out letters from people you are sure support you. It may sound obvious, but many people don’t. Find someone who truly likes you, and who supports your decision to apply for PA training. If you are unsure, ask them: “I am going to be applying to physician assistant schools, and I’m beginning to think about my letters of reference. Would you feel able to support me by writing a letter of reference if I asked you to?” If their response is anything less than an enthusiastic “Yes!” then consider finding someone else.

5. Use the electronic submission method if at all possible. Electronic submissions are easier on you, your reference, CASPA, and the schools you hope to attend. Simply provide CASPA with the name, title, degree, and email address of your reference, and how he or she knows you. Let your references know in advance when you will be submitting their information so they can gauge when the letter will need to be written. Once they have completed their letter they will email it to CASPA. Exception: if you are submitting a letter from an admissions committee. Letters from committees count as a single letter and must submitted as hard copies, on institution letterhead.

6. Waive your right to review your letters. CASPA gives you the option to waive your right to review your letters, and you should. Not waiving this right signifies that you may wish to view them yourself, and implies that you aren’t confident that they speak well of you. This is a little like like asking a potential employer not to contact your previous employer - a definite red flag to an applications committee.

7. When complete, send a thank you card to your letter writers (and maybe even a small gift — Starbucks gift cards are appropriate). This is just good manners. It shows your appreciation and keeps you in their good graces should you need to reapply next year.

Once your letters are completed and submitted, you can cross this item off your extensive to-do list and breathe a little easier. Good luck!

  • tee July 13, 2011, 1:30 pm

    how soon can application be filled out? ill be applying c/o 2015 and im shadowing now and would hopefully have this pa write me a letter, but im not sure if its too far in advance.

    Reply
    • Paul July 13, 2011, 2:12 pm

      Double check this with CASPA, but CASPA application are only accepted in cycles, beginning the April before the Fall that students start (April 2011 for classes beginning Fall of 2012). If you plan to graduate in 2015, then you can submit beginning April of 2012. This gives you some time to shadow and make an even better impression. This will be more good material your reference can include in your letter - the better they know you, the better the letter they can write for you. I STRONGLY encourage you to seek out electronic letters, rather than paper - much easier!

      - around 3 mos before you will submit your completed application (your part completed, that is), formally ask them if they will write for you.
      - around 1-2 mos before you submit, reconfirm that they are still willing/able. Tell them the process at this time and let them know that they can write a draft of the letter anytime on MS Word, etc. so that they will be able to copy and paste this draft into the CASPA electronic reference form that they will be receiving soon. REQUEST THAT THEY SAVE A COPY OF THEIR LETTER ON THEIR OWN COMPUTER, IN CASE THERE ARE ANY PROBLEMS (This happened to me, and I was prepared).
      - Submit your CASPA application and provide contact info for your letter writers as a part of the application.
      - CASPA sends each of your references an email with an electronic reference form that they fill out and return via email.
      - Monitor your application status closely to make sure that the letters are received - CASPA won’t send your application to any schools until everything is received! It’s your responsibility, not CASPA’s, to make sure that they get done, and many professors/clinicians are disorganize/busy/forgetful.

      It sounds complicated, but it’s actually a pretty good system, and not so complicated. Hope this helps. -Paul

      Reply
  • Diana Diaz January 3, 2012, 8:32 pm

    Hello! Thank you for the excellent fount of information here! I have been working with in Clinical Research for the past year and have secured an excellent reference from one of the Investigators I work with. However, I am about to obtain another job in the same field. I have a paper letter of recommendation but do not plan to apply to school for the next two years. What should I do in order to not lose this opportunity and excellent reference? Thanks in advance!

    Reply
    • Paul January 3, 2012, 9:43 pm

      Be sure to get the reference’s contact information and let them know that you’ll keep in touch. Give them regular updates of your progress (once or twice a year is sufficient). When you let them know you’ll be contacting them to use as a reference in the future, encourage them to make a digital copy of your letter (MS Word doc or similar), and save it so they don’t need to rewrite it in the future.

      We much prefer digital letters of reference, but if you must use a paper letter, you could ask them for an undated, signed, sealed, return-addressed copy of the letter so that you could drop it in the mail when it’s time. Don’t forget to have them include CASPA cover page and ratings sheet, as outlined on this page of CASPA.

      We think that references are relationships to be cultivated/maintained, so keeping is key to this process.
      Great question! -P

      Reply
  • Lilian Tang January 29, 2012, 6:39 pm

    Hi! I’m so thankful for your website, it is filled with so many useful tips and pointers!! I have shadowed this PA once last year and am planning to shadow her again in the coming weeks. I was wondering how many times should I shadow her before asking for a letter of recommendation? Of if I even should ask her for one..? And how to go about asking her? Thank you!

    Reply
    • Paul January 29, 2012, 8:09 pm

      Hi, Lilian - what a great question! It shows that you understand that a letter of recommendation is kind of a big deal.

      I would say several times at least, but more importantly, I would wait until you feel like you and she have some kind of relationship. Letters are best from those who like us and really support our application. Getting to know a person takes time, and no one wants to risk committing a letter to someone who they feel is still an unknown quantity. Why don’t you commit to shadowing once a week or once a month for a few months and see how it feels? By then you’ll know if she’s right to ask, and if the timing is right.

      As for how, I think it’s a good idea to ask in some way similar to this. “I’m going to be applying to PA programs soon. Do you feel like you are in a position to support my application?”

      This gives them a graceful out if they can’t for some reason. If you sense any hemming and hawing or hesitance on their part, let it go. In most cases, if you’ve handled yourself well, anyone who is willing to support you will gladly say yes. So if they say, “Sure” you ask them “Would you be willing to write a letter in support of my application?” You’re asking, but only because they’ve already all but told you they will. I like this method because you are putting out your feelers for how supportive they are while giving them a great opportunity to decline if for any reason they want or need to. The last thing you want is either 1) to make them feel obligated or 2) get a letter from someone whose heart just isn’t in it.

      Finally, letters are easier for them to write and more convincing the more time you have spent with them. That way they can honestly say that they know you well. So spend as much time with them as you can.

      Reply
  • lorena castro April 4, 2012, 12:14 pm

    I did shadowing in a foreign country but i haven’t been able to do it in the US, can i use that doctor for the letter of recomendation?

    Reply
    • Paul April 4, 2012, 12:35 pm

      You can, but I would strongly recommend that you get some shadowing in the US. If you can’t do that, then you might look at other ways to sell it, such as working as a volunteer overseas, or medical missions work. Obviously, be honest about what your duties were.

      Reply
  • Martinez April 15, 2012, 12:38 am

    Hi Paul,

    I am a registered respiratory therapist and was looking to apply to PA school this coming cycle for 2013. There are not many PAs that I work with but there are three MDs I work with who are more than happy to write letters of recommendation. My question is: Does it matter if the LOR is from a MD vs a PA?

    Reply
    • Paul April 15, 2012, 9:45 am

      No, that should be fine. You might want to limit to one MD so you can get a variety - say one supervisor, one doc, and one faculty member where you took your prerequisites. But if that isn’t possible, using both docs should be okay. Consider a letter from the PA
      You shadowed.

      Reply
  • Chris April 24, 2012, 8:31 am

    Hi Paul,
    I’ve followed three PAs in different settings; ED, orthopedic clinic, and a primary care clinic (I also volunteer here). I have a non-traditional background where I started as medical administration specialist in the Air Force for 4+ years, became an Advertising Executive for 13 years, and for the past year and a half I have been going back to school for my pre-requistes and volunteering at hospitals and clinics. I also attended EMT school and will also be taking my EMT national certification test next week.

    My volunteer time included working along side Physical Therapists, Occupational Therapists, and RNs and approximately accounts for 300 hours. My shadowing experience is approximately 80 hours.

    Since letters from PAs seem to be so highly valued, would you recommend obtaining three letters of recommendation from the three PAs I shadowed or “diversify” a bit more? I felt we had a great working relationship and I still continue to follow them when our schedules permit.

    Thank you!

    Reply
  • Michelle April 26, 2012, 8:07 am

    Hi Paul,

    I am a reapplicant for the 2013 cycle. I am wondering if I should use the same (2/3) Recommendation letters from last year. I know it is not encouraged, but it’s hard to find an instructor that I still have contact with and who knows me well. This year, some schools are ones that I have applied to, but many are new. I really feel bad to have my instructor and supervisor write another recommendation letter for me, since that’ll posts too much work for them. Besides, I am sure that I am still the same person with the same experience that they wrote about.

    I am in a dilemma here. Any advice is appreciated. Thanks in advance!

    Michelle

    Reply
  • Eugene May 15, 2012, 1:30 pm

    Hi Paul,

    Im applying this fall to matriculate in 2013. I wanted your opinion on recommendation letters from Nurse Practitioners instead of PA’s. I’m a Scribe in the ER and have known several NP’s for 3 years.

    Eugene

    Reply
    • Paul May 15, 2012, 9:19 pm

      A doc or PA would probably be better, but I don’t think a letter from an NP is bad. If they know you well, love you, and can write a good letter, then use ONE of them for a letter. Then find two more letters from:

      one or two from:
      Doc or PA

      and/or one from
      Boss or professor

      Reply
  • Lyn May 21, 2012, 11:59 pm

    Hi Paul,

    I work in the OR as a surgical technician, and did a little CNA work before that for a couple years. I graduated with a BS in biology in 2007, and my GPA from my undergrad just barely meets the requirement for the schools I’m applying to. I went to Surgical Technology school right after undergrad and did very well in my classes. I’ve been working as a surg tech for over 2 years now and work with many PA’s and obviously surgeons. I asked a surgeon that’s always supported my goal of being a PA for a letter of recommendation, and he gladly said yes. I will definitely ask a PA for a letter also, but now I can’t decide if I should ask another surgeon or my surgical tech teacher for the third reference. Both were also always supportive of my PA goals, but I was thinking my surg tech teacher could speak on my academic performance? I know surgical tech school was not quite graduate level work, but I was more focused and loved the hands-on learning style, so I did well in the program. What do you think? I would appreciate any help. Thank you!

    ~Lyn

    Reply
  • Maggie June 17, 2012, 4:55 pm

    Hi Paul,

    I’m requesting letters of recommendation from my shadowed doctors. One of the doctor gave ma a perfect ranking on the electronic application. I want to know from the 1-5 rating..if the doctor selected excellent on all the questions, would that be at my disadvantage? I feel that a perfect LOR might not be as beneficial as to a LOR with variation in ranking from 4-5 variation. Thanks for the help!

    Reply
    • Paul June 17, 2012, 8:14 pm

      I understand your question - does a perfect score on your letters of recommendation look “too perfect” to be true? It’s hard to say. I would hope that anyone who would score you so highly would include some positive and detailed narrative descriptions of you to make it clear they spent some time on the letter and care about what it says about you. I have had preceptors who said that they left some “above average” scores on my evals so that things wouldn’t look unrealistically positive, but if they had asked me, I think I would have told them that perfect was fine with me. :)

      Reply
  • Cassie June 20, 2012, 9:17 am

    Hi Paul,
    I am currently working on my application in CASPA and already have two letters of recommendation secured by both a Doc and a PA, I was in the Navy for five years (Corpsman) and was wondering if it would be acceptable to have my final letter written by my Chief, Independent Duty Corpsman, as we worked closely and he was in charge of patient care in our aid station? Thanks :)

    Reply
    • Paul June 20, 2012, 10:12 am

      I would think so - they’re experienced in medicine and know you and your work well. If you have any doubts, though, call the schools you want to get into and see what they say.

      Reply
  • Metali Shah August 6, 2012, 10:50 am

    Hi Paul,

    I have been shadowing a PA for about two months now and I am going to ask him for letter of recommendation. However, his last name is same as mine and we are not related. I found him through a friend. If he were to write me a letter how would that look on the application?

    Reply
    • Paul August 6, 2012, 10:19 pm

      I don’t think this is a problem. Just be sure to explain your dilemma, and ask him - whatever else he writes about you - to make sure to include that you are “no relation.” This happens - they shouldn’t have a huge problem with it.

      Reply

Leave a Comment

Navigation